|
The conventional approach to residential PV system installations involves design, engineering, documentation, sourcing of components, receiving and handling, warehousing and unique on-site installation. An alternative approach is to use system packages, sometimes referred to as kits. Here I define solar electric system packages, examine their advantages and disadvantages, outline the situations where they make the most sense and provide a chronology of an installation utilizing a commercially available, off-the-shelf kit. WHAT GOES INTO A PV SYSTEM PACKAGE? Photovoltaic system packages are preengineered, documented, complete systems. They are ordered with a single part number and are available in a wide range of configurations from a variety of sources that include module manufacturers, distributors and integrators.
Preengineered. System packages are professionally designed and engineered to standard specifications. The components are selected, based on substantial experience and testing, to work well with each other and to endure for the life of the system. No weak links can cause system failure due to improper design, and broad code compliance is incorporated. In some cases, the systems are reviewed and approved by independent agencies such as the Florida Solar Energy Center and other governmental agencies. Proper engineering produces systems that can perform well in a wide range of site-specific environmental conditions.
 Documented Preengineered packages come fully documented and typically include a three-line electrical drawing, mechanical drawings, installation drawings and instructions, a complete bill of materials (BOM) and specification sheets and warranties for major components. The electrical and mechanical drawings make kits ?permit ready? for most building departments. A site-specific roof plan is typically the only additional documentation needed to apply for and pull a permit. The same documentation often facilitates the inspection process and provides a comprehensive package for the homeowner.
Complete systems. System packages contain all the major components needed for installation, including modules, inverter, racking and minor parts like fittings and hardware for module fastening and grounding. A typical exception is the source-circuit conductors between the array and the inverter, which must be sized for the particular installation. System packages are bundled in a distributor?s warehouse and shipped via common carrier. They typically come delivered on three or more plastic wrapped pallets.
Single part number. System packages are ordered using a single part number as opposed to the customer?s creating a BOM. The supplier maintains an inventory of all the items on the BOM provided for the system to ensure off-the-shelf availability and often 1- to 2-day order fulfillment.
A wide range of configurations. Preengineered packages, due to the variety of system sizes and installer or customer requirements, are available in a wide range of combinations and permutations. To be viable, system kits must offer sufficient variation to match most real world situations in terms of physical array size, energy production requirements, price and component manufacturer preferences. In some cases, packages without racking may be available, thereby increasing a system?s flexibility as it can be used with flat roof, ground- or pole-mounting applications.
 TRADE-OFFS OF PV SYSTEM PACKAGES Utilizing system packages has some general advantages and disadvantages compared to the conventional customized approach. The basic trade-offs are convenience versus material cost and simplicity versus flexibility.
ADVANTAGES
Minimal engineering required. Using a preengineered system frees solar contractors from the details of system design; they are guaranteed a reliable, proven and standard system. The specified inverter and modules are carefully paired. The module string sizing is not only correct, but it also incorporates a safety margin allowing the system to function well in a range of conditions and locations. However, it may be up to the installer to verify that a given site?s average high and historical low temperatures will not impact the system?s function due to array voltages outside of the inverter?s power point tracking range or that exceed the inverter?s maximum voltage limit. The bottom line is that kits eliminate most of the design time a solar engineer would need to spend on a specific residential project. This can allow a solar business to redirect resources to other functions, such as sales and marketing.
Less system documentation to create. The inclusion of electrical and mechanical drawings translates to less time spent putting together a submittal package for the local building department. Project specific CAD drawing is eliminated or greatly reduced and simplified.
 Convenience and time savings.With the conventional approach, installers need to develop a comprehensive BOM and source the components from one or more distributors. This is a time consuming task that is subject to error, particularly for new installers who lack experience. Lead times on system components, particularly modules, can vary. As a result, materials must be ordered accordingly, inventoried and pulled when the job starts. This requires shop space, nimble logistical skills and significant handling.
PV system packages are logistically simpler. Ordering with a single part number saves time. Off-the-shelf availability minimizes lead time and guarantees everything will arrive together. In some cases, the system can even be drop-shipped right to the job site. Customer satisfaction is increased due to the shortened time span from the day a contract is signed to the day the system is commissioned. Installation is not interrupted because a part was not ordered or loaded. In addition, less skilled labor can be used because of the simplicity of packaged systems, and the installation learning curve is short?usually one or two systems?speeding each successive installation.
Starting operations in new territories.When an installation business expands into a new state or a distant geography, system packages may enable that operation to ramp up more quickly with minimal overhead and less field installation support, which in turn frees up company resources.
DISADVANTAGES
Higher material cost. PV system packages cost more than purchasing the individual components and parts. The added value in terms of engineering, documentation and logistics typically adds a premium of approximately 8%?10%. As a result, high volume installers typically do not use kits. Their economies of scale enable them to purchase in large quantities and minimize their overhead costs effectively. They also have the experience and expertise to design and document systems. These installers have effectively developed their own system packages.
Less flexibility. The installer is constrained by the selection of modules and inverters available in preengineered packages. The roof attachments may be limited to composition shingle roofs. Depending on the package, roof penetration flashing systems may need to be purchased separately. Also, standardized system designs cannot be applied in some situations, such as at sites with localized shading from dormers or a roof surface that is significantly obstructed by plumbing or air vents. Systems may need to be custom designed to satisfy these conditions.
WHO BENEFITS MOST FROM KITS? Clearly, solar electric system packages are not for everyone, but several categories of installers can benefit from using them.
Novice installers. System packages are ideal for new entrants into the solar installation business, because preengineered systems embed the design experience that the novice solar contractor lacks. They allow the business to focus on the areas where the company does have experience and can excel, such as sales and installation. Here, system kits help keep the installer out of trouble, ensure a quality system for the customer and safeguard the reputation of the industry. They represent the best formula for success for someone new to the business.
Small or low volume installers. Preengineered systems also make sense for small or low volume installers, including broader focused renewable energy or green home companies. These businesses do not specialize in PV installation but offer it as part of a larger portfolio of services. Small companies that operate from a home or a small storefront with limited shop space often pick up packaged systems from the freight carrier?s dock or have them drop-shipped to the job site. These kinds of installers often cannot justify the overhead involved in the engineering, purchasing, inventory and logistics of custom systems.
Installers wanting a simpler approach. Regardless of volume, PV system packages offer installers a streamlined business model that can emphasize sales, marketing and installation.
THE PACKAGED SYSTEM PROCESS Selling, sourcing and installing PV system packages is fundamentally similar to the conventional design-from-scratch approach, except it is simpler in many ways. There are also processes unique to the installation of system packages. These are described below using SunWize?s Grid-Tie Systems as an example. Other suppliers? approaches may vary, but the process is generally similar supplier to supplier. Step one: system selection. Site evaluation for PV system packages is no different from conventional systems. What is different is how the system is sized and selected. The conventional procedure is for a solar consultant or salesperson to evaluate the site in terms of roof orientation, roof pitch, available roof area and shading. That site information would then be turned over to a designer at the office along with electricity usage data and the customer?s energy production objective. PV system packages, being preengineered, enable the solar consultant to size and select the system during the initial site visit using a configuration table. Once the desired system output is determined, the first and most critical configuration decision is the selection of the module. SunWize Grid-Tie System packages have three module choices that provide a spectrum of price points and efficiencies: Sanyo (high efficiency and price), Sharp (midrange efficiency and price) and Kaneka (low efficiency and price). For instance, if roof space is limited, then the Sanyo HIT 200 will likely be the best module choice to meet the customer?s production goal. Using this as an example, the solar consultant then goes to the Sanyo section of the configuration table. Once the module has been selected, the solar consultant needs to choose the inverter. The inverter choice may be driven by factors such as the installer?s preference of manufacturer. SunWize Grid-Tie Systems offer inverters from three leading manufacturers: Fronius, SMA America and Xantrex. The consultant then goes to the subsection for the inverter manufacturer of choice, say Xantrex. Next, the solar consultant locates the configuration with the desired array output in either STC or CEC watts dc within the Sanyo/Xantrex section of the configuration table. The consultant then decides whether the system needs to be ordered with or without racking. Perhaps the site requires a ground-mounted instead of roof-mounted array, or the roofing material is a standing seam metal and the S-5! clamp system will be used to mount the modules.
On the initial sales visit, the solar consultant, already knowing the dimensions of the specified modules, can determine how to best arrange them on the roof. PV system arrays are modular in their design, enabling them to be configured in a variety of ways?portrait, landscape, one large array, two or more smaller arrays and so forth. SunWize packages its modules into ?panels? of three, four or five modules. The panels can be mounted separately or connected to one another using rail splice kits.
 Step two: purchasing and delivery. Once a system is selected, purchasing is simple. An order is placed using the unique single part number for the system. Because all system components are in stock, installers can time the purchase close to the installation date, minimizing their carrying costs and improving cash flow. Installers can request the electrical drawing ahead of system delivery to complete the permit submittal package.
Installers can have systems shipped to their shop or, because everything is shipped together, directly to the job site. Job site delivery is logistically more challenging because the timing is difficult to predict. Not only does someone have to meet the delivery, but also the delivery address often has to be accessible to a semitruck. The installer can specify a truck equipped with a lift gate and pallet jack for easier unloading. Another option is to pick up the shipment at the freight carrier?s dock and take it to the job. Aside from routine inspection for freight damage, the installer simply double checks that all parts were delivered, using a complete BOM included with the shipping documents.
Step three: installation and inspection.Prior to installation, the lead installer typically makes a site visit to determine the inverter mounting location and to size the homerun cabling before purchasing the conductors, conduit and fittings for the runs between the array and the inverter and the inverter and the electrical panel.
Once the crew arrives at the site, installing a system package is virtually identical to installing a custom designed system. That is, all the components and parts are present and installed according to standard practices. Again, with PV system packages, the installation is less likely to be disrupted while someone makes a run for a missing part.
Using system kits can make it easier to build good relationships with building officials. In some areas with volume package sales, local inspectors have developed a level of familiarity and comfort with preengineered systems. In many ways this is similar to the relationship that designers and installers of custom systems build over time with inspectors, but it happens more quickly. The detailed documentation provided with preengineered systems and their wide deployment may speed sound relationships between the installer and the AHJ.
The handoff of the system to the customer is enhanced by the documentation provided with system packages. Customers receive not only the technical drawings and installation instructions but also all the manufacturers? manuals and warranty information in one binder?something that is often overlooked by busy installers getting ready for the next job.
PREDICTING THE FUTURE OF PV SYSTEM PACKAGES PV system packages will eventually dominate the market for residential systems, whether they are developed by distributors, manufacturers or installers. As the market continues to grow, the disparity between the largest and smallest installers will also increase. As larger companies absorb midsized installers, the landscape will eventually consist of a small top tier of increasingly larger installation companies and an increasingly wide variety of small players.
The broad bottom tier will include more electrical, roofing and general contractors diversifying into solar as the housing market struggles to recover. PV system packages will serve the needs of that tier. The top tier will effectively develop its own system packages, and these will form the backbone of its residential business. This latter trend is well underway as larger installers standardize their designs in the interests of efficiency and cost savings.
Residential solar electric systems will continue their evolution from custom designed systems to off-the-shelf electricity generating "appliances." Preengineered systems will continue to play a key role in this evolution. REF: http://solarprofessional.com/
|